Countermand 1-Tripura West Polling – Hold a Fresh Poll

April 30, 2019

A delegation of Communist Party of India (Marxist) led by its General Secretary Sitaram Yechury and consisting of Polit Bureau member Nilotpal Basu, Left Front Candidate for Tripura West Parliamentary Constituency Sankar Prasad Datta and Left Front Candidate for Tripura  East Parliamentary Constituency Jitendra Chowdhury met the Election Commission of India today to discuss about the poll related issues in Tripura.  The delegation handed over a letter to the Chief Election Commissioner demanding a fresh poll for the Tripura West Parliamentary Constituency.

Text of the letter is enclosed herewith for publication.

(Hari Singh Kang)

For CPI(M) Central Committee office


Dear Shri Aroraji,

Sub: Countermand 1-Tripura West Polling – Hold a Fresh Poll

We have come to the conclusion that the process of elections for 1-Tripura West Parliamentary Constituency, which was held on April 11, 2019, was marred by  large-scale irregularities and outright rigging.  We have depended on the findings of the Election Commission of India (ECI) itself and documents available to us in that process.

Before going into the specifics of the poll irregularity, its extent and the necessary remedial action thereof, we would like to draw your attention to the fact that since February 20, 2019, we have brought to your notice the specific details of our apprehension about the possible threats to holding of free and fair poll.  We had met the Commission on March 6, two days before the announcement and the notification of the polls. Regrettably, our worst apprehensions have been vindicated based on the actual developments.

It is here that we had specifically raised the issue of the suitability of appointing the Returning Officer (RO) for the 1-Tripura West Parliamentary Constituency.  We had categorically pointed out that the RO, in his role as the District Magistrate, had passed an order for stopping the publication, Daily Desharkatha, which smacked of partisanship against the progressive forces of the state (Annexure I).  The Hon’ble Chief Justice of the High Court of Tripura found this order not appropriate for implementation and stayed any further action.  In the light of this and in keeping with precedents about the role of officers who have been implicitly restrained  by the judiciary, he should not have been found suitable for holding crucial polling responsibility.  However, based on its inputs from the Tripura state administration, the Commission did not find anything amiss and continued with the same officer as the Returning Officer.

Based on our complaints and the responses from the observers and others, the ECI had come to the conclusion that the experience of April 11 was grave enough for postponing the 2-Tripura East (ST) Parliamentary Constituency on April 18 as scheduled.    The ECI notification observed that: “Whereas reports have been received from the Chief Electoral Officer, Tripura and from the Special Police Observer, Tripura that the law and order situation prevailing in the said 2-Tripura East (ST) Parliamentary Constituency is not conducive to the holding of free and fair poll in the constituency on 18th April, 2019”. (Annexure II)

Seldom one finds such drastic action, on behalf of the ECI and all in the wake of the actual experience of 11th April, the process of enquiry has brought out extremely disturbing facts.

A series of orders had been issued – starting from 16th April 2019 (Annexure III-A) and then on 17th April (Annexure III-B) and on 18th April (Annexure III-C) and on 19th April (Annexure III-D) – all detailing out various aspects of irregularities and fixing responsibility of several officers.

In the final document in the series of official documents available with us dated April 23, the RO had written to the Additional Chief Electoral Officer making a comprehensive statement  about irregularities in 433 booths (Annexure IV).

However, we have been given to understand that at the instance of the Special Observer, there are efforts to reduce the number of booths, where admittedly irregularities have occurred and, therefore, necessitated re-polling.

The fact of the matter is that the scale of rigging and manipulation was much larger.  In the evening of April 11, based on preliminary reports, we had requested  for re-polling in 464 booths out of total 1,679 booths.

Subsequently, after the total information became available,  we had demanded for re-polling in 846 booths.  There is no doubt in our mind that more than 50 per cent of the legitimate voters could not cast their vote on the April 11, but, strangely, even after 20 days, the ECI has not been able to come to any definitive conclusion.  There is  now a widespread perception among the people of Tripura that unlike anytime in the past, the ECI could not redeem its commitment of holding a free and fair poll in the state. In fact, there is a strong resentment that not only has the ECI failed the holding of democratic elections, but it is also hesitant to initiate remedial measures.

In the light of all these, we commend the demand of the Left Front Committee of Tripura to countermand the entire election in 1-Tripura West Parliamentary Constituency and hold a fresh poll for the entire Parliamentary Constituency (Annexure V). It will be worthwhile to refer to the firm decision that was taken by the ECI in countermanding the polls for the Vellore Parliamentary Constituency in Tamilnadu on the proof that some money was recovered which would allegedly vitiate the polling process in the said constituency.

With regards,

Yours sincerely

Sd/-                                                                      Sd/-

(Sitaram Yechury)                                              (Nilotpal Basu)

General Secretary                                                 Member, Polit Bureau